Nazim Hikmet:
The Most Strange of Creatures
Like the scorpion, my brother,
You are like the scorpion
In a terror-stricken night,
Like the sparrow, my brother,
You are like the sparrow
In inconsiderable restlessness.
Like the mussel, my brother,
You are like the mussel
Closed tight and tranquil.
You are terrible, my brother,
Like the mouth of an extinguished volcano.
And you are not one, alas,
you are not five
you are some millions.
You are like the sheep, my brother,
When the butcher dressed in your wool
when the butcher lifts his Staff
you hurry yourself to get back in the flock
and you go to the slaughterhouse running, almost proud.
You are the most strange of creatures, in short,
More strange than the fish
who lives in the sea without knowing the sea,
And if there is so much misery on the earth
it is thanks to you, my brother,
If we are starved, worn out,
If we are flayed till the blood flows,
Pressed like a bunch of grapes to yield our wine,
Will I go so far as to say that it is your fault, no,
But for many it is so, my brother.
----------
I once heard a beautiful French rendition by Yves Montand (I believe it was on his 1981 World Tour), and I think this is the text he used:
La plus drôle des créatures
Comme le scorpion, mon frère
Tu es comme le scorpion
Dans une nuit d'épouvante.
Comme le moineau, mon frère,
Tu es comme le moineau
Dans ses menues inquiétudes.
Comme la moule, mon frère,
Tu es comme la moule
Enfermée et tranquille.
Tu es terrible, mon frère,
Comme la bouche d'un volcan éteint.
Et tu n'es pas un, hélas,
Tu n'es pas cinq,
Tu es des millions.
Tu es comme le mouton, mon frère,
Quand le bourreau habillé de ta peau
Quand le bourreau lève son bâton
Tu te hâtes de rentrer dans le troupeau
Et tu vas à l'abattoir en courant, presque fier.
Tu es la plus drôle des créatures, en somme,
Plus drôle que le poisson
Qui vit dans la mer sans savoir la mer.
Et s'il y a tant de misère sur terre
C'est grâce à toi mon frère,
Si nous sommes affamés, épuisés,
Si nous sommes écorchés jusqu'au sang,
Pressés comme la grappe pour donner notre vin,
Irai-je jusqu'à dire que c'est de ta faute, non,
Mais tu y es pour beaucoup, mon frère.
---------------
I prefer this French version to the English but for obvious reasons I posted both.
tom
Nazim Hikmet - The Most Strange of Creatures
This section is for any other poetry-related topics
- tom.d.stiller
- Posts: 1213
- Joined: Fri Mar 07, 2003 8:18 am
- Location: ... between the lines ...
- Contact:
Return to “Other Writers and Writing”
Jump to
- News
- General
- ↳ THE FLAME - news and information
- ↳ Montreal Memorial Week, November 2017
- ↳ Leonard Cohen 80 years on September 21, 2014
- ↳ Comments & Questions
- ↳ Tribute concerts, Cover versions & Soundtracks
- ↳ Collectors' and Traders' Corner
- ↳ Leonard Cohen 75 years (September 21, 2009)
- The Music Place
- ↳ Thanks for the Dance
- ↳ You Want It Darker
- ↳ 2015 Release: Can't Forget
- ↳ 2014 releases: Popular Problems & Live in Dublin
- ↳ OLD IDEAS
- ↳ Leonard Cohen's music
- ↳ Live performances & YouTube clips
- ↳ New Songs & Rarities
- ↳ Live in London, Dear Heather, The Essential Leonard Cohen, Ten New Songs
- ↳ Blue Alert
- ↳ Related Artists
- ↳ Adam Cohen
- ↳ Other music
- The Poetry Place
- ↳ Book of Longing
- ↳ Leonard Cohen's poetry and novels
- ↳ Writing, Music and Art by the Forum members
- ↳ Other Writers and Writing
- World Tours 2008-2010 & 2012-2013
- ↳ TOUR 2013 IN AUSTRALIA AND NEW ZEALAND
- ↳ THE SUMMER 2013 TOUR IN EUROPE
- ↳ THE SPRING 2013 TOUR IN NORTH AMERICA
- ↳ USA & CANADA 2012 / CONCERT REPORTS & MEET-UPS
- ↳ Old Ideas World Tour 2012 / Europe
- ↳ EUROPE 2012 / CONCERT REPORTS & MEET-UPS
- ↳ Old Ideas World Tour 2012 / USA and Canada
- ↳ The World Tour 2010
- ↳ The World Tour 2010 Meetups
- ↳ The Fall 2009 Tour in USA
- ↳ The Summer Tour in Europe 2009
- ↳ The North American Tour 2009
- ↳ The Pacific Tour 2009
- ↳ The Fall Tour in Europe 2008
- ↳ The Summer Tour 2008
- The Leonard Cohen Events
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Copenhagen in 2024
- ↳ Hydra Meetups 2023, 2019, 2017, 2015, 2013, 2011, 2009, 2007, 2005 & The Event in 2002
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Ghent 2022
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event 2020 in Ghent, Belgium - RESCHEDULED TO 2022
- ↳ Walking Weekends (2009 - 2023)
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Budapest 2018
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Amsterdam 2016
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Dublin 2014
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Madison 2012
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Krakow 2010
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Edmonton 2008
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in Berlin 2006
- ↳ The Leonard Cohen Event in New York 2004
- ↳ Other gatherings
- ↳ Traveling Pack
- Everything Else